Has Cristiano Ronaldo Surpassed Lionel Messi?

Updated: 12 July 2016 18:20 IST

After winning Euro 2016, has Cristiano Ronaldo surpassed Lionel Messi as the greatest footballer of the current generation? NDTV's football pundits Scott O'Donell and Novy Kapadia present contrasting arguments

Has Cristiano Ronaldo Surpassed Lionel Messi?
While Messi failed to take Argentina to Copa America victory, Ronaldo did it for Portugal in Euro 2016. © AP

Cristiano Ronaldo captured his first major trophy with Portugal and that has added international honours to his long list of club medals. Lionel Messi, meanwhile, failed to take Argentina over the line in the Copa America final against Chile. So, has Ronaldo now surpassed Messi as the greatest footballer of this generation?

Who would you pick if you were coach?

Novy Kapadia: If I was looking for a striker, I would pick Cristiano Ronaldo. I don't think anyone can head the ball better than him, only Alan Shearer could.

Scott O' Donell: For me the best thing about Messi is that he is a team player. He provides as many assists as he scores. Ronaldo will never pass the ball if he thinks he can score. If I was coach and had to choose between the two, I would pick Messi any day.

Ronaldo mentally tougher than Messi?

Novy Kapadia: In mental toughness Ronaldo has gone a step ahead of Messi after winning the Euro. He took Portugal to the final, and even though he played just 15 minutes, he was inspirational from the outside. One thing is certain now: Ronaldo is winning his fourth Ballon d'or.

Scott O' Donell: How can one game in which Ronaldo didn't contribute enough make him mentally tougher. In fact I thought Portugal benefitted when Ronaldo left the field because he isn't known for his defensive abilities, and when he was substituted, it allowed Portugal to play 10 men in defence that proved to be the winning strategy in the end. Also how can Ronaldo be mentally tougher when he allows emotions to get in the way of how he plays. Messi on the other hand gets kicked, but he gets up. He doesn't argue with the referee, doesn't argue with his coaches. He just gets up and does his job.

Messi more prolific goal scorer than Ronaldo?

lionel messi cristiano ronaldo 1207
Cristiano Ronaldo has scored 61 international goals while Lionel Messi has 55 to his name.


Novy Kapadia: Messi has a better goal average because he plays for Barcelona, probably the most dominant team that club football has ever seen.

Scott O' Donell: When has Ronaldo played for a weak club team? Manchester United and Real Madrid had stars as big as anyone playing alongside Ronaldo.

Messi doesn't have a major international title

Scott O' Donell: I would count the 2008 Olympic gold and the Under-20 World Cup that Messi won with Argentina as major international titles. Yes, the Olympic team is made up of under-23 players and only three senior players are allowed, but ask Brazil how important an Olympic gold in football is, a title they have never won, and are so desperate to win that they decided to rest their star player Neymar for the Copa America Centenario, so that he could play at the Rio Olympics.

Novy Kapadia: Olympic gold is indeed a great achievement. But the pressure one feels at the Euro is only second to the World Cup.

Topics : Portugal Argentina Lionel Messi Cristiano Ronaldo Football
Related Articles
Virat Kohli, Anushka Sharma
Virat Kohli, Anushka Sharma's English Rendezvous With Shikhar Dhawan And Family. Have A Dekko
IPL Chairman Rajeev Shukla
IPL Chairman Rajeev Shukla's Aide Resigns Following Bribery Scandal
England To Play First Test Against Ireland Next July, Ashes From August 1 To September 16
England To Play First Test Against Ireland Next July, Ashes From August 1 To September 16
BCCI Suspends Stung UPCA Official Pending Probe
BCCI Suspends Stung UPCA Official Pending Probe
India vs England: Joe Root Regrets
India vs England: Joe Root Regrets 'Bat-Drop' Celebration, Says 'Most Embarrassing Thing I've Done'